The left, critiques of enlightenment and eonic transitions

Marxists seem to think that given a revolutionary seizure of society they can reconstruct society on their terms and eliminating everything as bourgeois etc…In fact the task would be monumental and nothing in the legacy of the various lefts suggests they have much idea of how to proceed.
One clue is the eonic model and its ‘transitions’: a rich source of the complex innovations that drive civilization, most of which are made a mess of in the later period…

From enlightenment values to a generalized secularist modernism
March 15th, 2017

The leftist critique of the enlightenment (The classic Dialectic of the Enlightenment is the most famous case) is both understandable and usually misguided. We have suggested a larger project of founding a leftist movement on a generalized framework of modernity and that includes a full set of complements: religion and reformation, the scientific revolution, the revolutions of the early modern, liberalism, utopian, ideas of freedom, a revolution in philosophy (kant, hegel, schopenhauer…), the enlightenment as such in six versions, german, dutch, english, scottish, french, etc…

And so on. A useful framework is that of the eonic effect and the way it enforces a ‘dialectical’ spectrum of multiple opposites. A revolutionary left based on positivistic materialism of the nineteenth century is too narrow and has been left behind in the era when even quantum mechanics has challenged crude materialistic viewpoints.

The left had a natural ambivalence to modernity but in the end it must be able to create societies that are robustly modernist without eliminating all the social factors that we see in what we call the ‘modern transition’:

From Reformation to Revolution: in WHEE, chapter 7

A recent call for the left to adopt enlightenment values is excellent but too narrow: what are enlightenment values?
If we adopt the perspective of the eonic effect we can adopt a true universalism we consider as relevant the entire spectrum of civilizational histories shown in the so-called macrosequence…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s